On the surface, it was a simple drug deal.
In January 2015, 15-year-old Ryan Hardwick and 16-year-old Deauntay Moye made a deal with 23-year-old Benjamin Holsinger to purchase some marijuana.
But when the teens arrived for the meet in Woodbury, Pa., instead they found Holsinger’s girlfriend, Stephanie Waters, and her dog, Duke. She was Holsinger’s proxy, there to sell them the pot they wanted. The Tribune-Democrat reported they drove to Woodbury Community Center to complete the transaction.
Instead of going their separate ways, Moye shot Waters execution-style in the neck. Hardwick killed Duke. They moved Waters, still alive, and Duke to the back seat of Waters’ car and went on a joyride as they smoked the weed.
Hardwick and Moye said Waters survived for about 20 minutes after being shot and chose not to take her to the hospital. They then abandoned the car. It and the bodies were found two days later.
Moye and Holsinger pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and Holsinger specifically admitting to killing Waters’ dog. Hardwick, now 17, was sentenced to 60 years to life in prison on Tuesday.
The judge noted the lack of Holsinger’s response as Waters’ family read statements before the court.
“Just because I don’t cry doesn’t mean I’m not remorseful,” Hardwick retorted.
“Other than entering his guilty plea, Mr. Hardwick has shown no remorse or acceptance of responsibility,” Higgins told The Tribune-Democrat. “This isn’t a guy who made a mistake and learned from it. He thinks everything is a big joke.”
Moye will be sentenced Dec. 2.
Holsinger admitted his role in the deal months after his girlfriend’s death. He pleaded guilty in October 2015.